Wednesday 19 February 2014

The Kejriwal Phenomenon

The downside slip of  Arvind Kejriwal,  as manifested by his dharna against Union Home Minister  for as frivolous a cause as the demand for suspension of some  policemen and then  grabbing the face saving offer of sending them on leave  for  withdrawing the agitation hastily , was as disappointing a phenomenon as phenomenal  and euphoric had been his emergence on political firmament with a bang . And now, his  exit from Delhi, after he could find an escape route to get pushed to  the national scene, with general elections round the corner, leaves  many  amongst millions, who had pinned hopes with him and his   Aam Admi Party, in a state of fix, though the aura  around him lingers on and  people seem to cling to him even now with the bag of hopes on their backs .  
Whatever be the case , this certainly leaves me, and perhaps many like me, worried  since we had  started looking at him as the harbinger of change   that the country so badly needs ,  the torch bearer  who may beacon light to put the nation on the right track. My worry emanates from  inevitable assessment that he is not the stuff  for the national scene, unless he shows up signs of dramatic changes  in his personality, attitude and  style of  working on a mission.  Not that I had expected miracle from him or from  his newly formed party. To be honest,  I had reservations initially  about Kejriwal and his party’s capability which I aired unhesitatingly only to be the butt of friendly  scoffs  in course of discussions in drawing rooms.
 I had reason for my  reservations about Kejriwal even on the face of his overwhelming popularity when he  wiped out the then  ruling party in the Assembly elections of Delhi. I had reservations because he could not measure in my eye to be really able to make a dent into the existing political system of India which , to my mind, is at the root of all ills and evils that have been   eating up the vitals of the country  like moth, leading to all round   frustrations  despite apparent glamour and prosperity. The fact is that we expected our democracy and democratic institutions   to come of age by now.  Instead,  what have matured and got deeply entrenched   into our socio-political life   are the  ills and evils associated with democracy.  Somehow, the system of governance, which otherwise  is deemed ideal for human existence with dignity, stands woefully polluted and  has become breeding ground for  ills and evils like corruption, nepotism ,parochialism, casteism, communalism, to name only a few.  I am afraid that an old adage: ‘Politics is the last refuge of a scoundrel’ may not become the order of the day later or sooner.  And the task of cleaning  the rotten  system  seems to be  an utopia, perhaps as impossible a task to achieve  as was the plan of the rats to tie a  bell round  the neck of   a cat which had been  hounding and devouring them one by one every day by stealthily treading on their space. Who was to do it?
But  I started  entertaining hopes with the new party and its leader, dismissing my earlier stance of disapproval , when I looked at Kejriwal’s  advent in political arena against the backdrop of this utterly  depressing scenario. When he  sent chilled waves in political circles, engulfing even  age old political parties,  shaking  even the political veterans of established  outfits  by buffets  of his stormy  victory in Delhi elections, I started  nourishing  the  thought  that , may be , he is the one who may lead the light in the right direction and put the nation on track. A ray of hope kindled on the horizon.  While his upward swing could be attributed to his superb leadership qualities and ability to pull masses who are desperate to locate an alternative to the existing political parties, doubts are now overtaking us that he may not really  come up to our tall expectations   because of some compulsive parts of his personality.   One of the  telling weaknesses  that his personality appears to reflect  as a leader   is his impulsive temperament . Once his brain is fired by an idea , his agitating mindset would not let him stop and think . He would jump the guns, whatever the results. And a massive systemic change in a country as vast and as diverse as India  does not come by thoughtless haste, howsoever sincere be the  intentions . It needs a cool and calculative mind added  to superb  leadership attributes that can make a difference.   
Kejriwal, perhaps, needs to be advised by the intellectual giants in the country who have so far chosen to  sit in their protected  professional boundaries  and then he may be  able to work out a sensible and foolproof  road map, after thread bare analysis of the ills that have crept in the system . It is only when wisdom is mixed with   emotions  that some tangible results can be expected, for emotional approach may pull the masses that may be needed to support the struggle, wisdom will guide the leadership to carve its way ahead to reach the set objectives. Otherwise, it remains  the cry in the wilderness.  


16 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with your views by and large. Very well analyzed. I feel Kejriwal is a game changer. Already major political parties have started following some of his principles to connect with the common man, particularly the common man who is poor. It is highly unlikely that he will fade away soon. Whether he is able to properly organize the AAP and bring some method and order in the streak of madness shown by him and some of his established team members only time can tell. However, his ability to connect with the masses and mobilize them is phenomenal.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sandeep, I agree with you that we have to watch in order to see , since he is now at the national scene,whether he will make a difference by bringing in some method and order in the streak of his madness. So far , there is nothing to suggest that he has chosen a course to swim against the flowing current. As was my fear he and his party would merge with hue and colour of the existing parties and start swimming with the current , with all the gimmicks traditional swimmers . Nevertheless, it is too early to conclude. The race has yet to reach the midstream . Let us watch and see.

      Delete
  3. i really like his ideology...He has set a benchmark that when people really want change they make that change..I thought for sometime that soon the rule will end but to end the rule we will need a push that kejriwal has given us...he was right about if you want to change the system you will have to get in the system..nowadays we never take politics as a career why?? because it is a disrespectful job for common man minds...it the thinking that those who can do nothing in life can get into politics thatswhy we have so arrogant ministers..i am not saying they are uneducated but they believe themselves above the law by having treated as VVIPs its the system which made them arrogant..To fight for good we need to indentify the evil or is blind war...There is a famous saying that "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing"

    -yash

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well said, nana. I also started looking him as a harbinger of change and I still believe that he will bring the necessary changes in the system as he has entered politics. We all know that he has done a good job as an activist by organising movements such as ‘Parivartan’ and another movement to pass the Right to information act. So, due to his acheivements as an activist, people like me still believe that he will incorporate some changes which will make the political system of India more rational and effective. He lacks certain qualities of a leader and due to this factor many people have lost faith in him and feel that he will not be able to make a difference.
    In my opinion , he has to incorporate some leadership qualities to make the difference in the Indian political system.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ishu, I agree with you that he has to 'incorporate some leadership qualities to make the difference' . But how? People donot change unless they want to change for which one has to introspect to locate ones weaknesses . As against this , Kejriwal seems to be living in fool's paradise assuming that he is the best and the rest of the world is nothing but the basket of rotten eggs. I do not know whgat to expect from such a person.

      Delete
  5. Ishu i disagree with you its not the leadership qualities that he lack moreover it the experience that he lack for being an activist you also require leader quality where leader quality means it influencing people to follow your thoughts or say moto... Mr.Kejriwal has done some mischief by resigning as CM now he is "Na ghar na,na ghat ka"... He should have stayed and improve the Delhi system first not going directly to the Indian National system...
    -yash

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yash, Kejriwal doesnot have any adeology . His appeal was by virtue of being an activist. He is indeed bestowed with some leadership qualities, nut they come to naught because some inherent weaknesses in his personality . Hence nothing really revolutionary can be expected . However , since he is at the natial scene , let us wastch and see.

      Delete
    2. Sorry Yash , some spelling mistakes. He has leadership qualities , but they are undone by his weakness . Hence, our expectations from him are misplaced .

      Delete
  6. After staying out of India for almost 9 years I am totally out of touch with what is going in Indian political circle and I am not the kind who watch NDTV or Aaj Tak regularly. However during my short visit last year AAP and Kejriwal was a topic everybody found very thought provoking and all "AAM AADMI" were very keen to discuss on what Kejriwal was doing and what he should do in future...... (with so many heated debates going around on AAP I even started wondering if I selected a wrong time to visit India, probably next time will check with election commission before booking tickets)... After returning I kept a close watch on what was going in Delhi and after elections it was clear as great leader Mr. Khan said "Don't underestimate the power of a common man" AAP passed with flying colours and thrashed all sweet dreams of bjp. .. I started believing that probably AAP is the new dawn for India... After that I went back to my old days and stopped following Indian politics thinking now my country is in safe hands... But after few days I read an article in Strait Times (TIMES of Singapore)
    that Delhi chief minister is on strike and protesting which forced me to look to click on NDTV application and reading few articles I found lot of similarities between Mr. KEJRIWAL and my 4 year old son Ansh both of them start protesting if something is not as per there liking and both go on hunger strike. To both my advice is hunger strike is not a solution but will only result in physical disorders... From no angle AAP actions were of a matured party led by a leader it was like a Jim Carey in Bruce Almighty where he was given power of God and then realised he could not handle it. .... I hope he AAP will not show similar results in lok sabha elections because it will be funny to have out prime minister going on hunger strike if United Nation won't agree to his point and also every election is expensive.... And with AAP Delhi episode it will cost India lot of money to have 2 general elections in single year.
    In short I fully agree with papaji comments :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mr Sakmat, there is not much to say after your most appropriate anologies to depict his persona .That really sums up his political modes and methods. However , since he has now plunged into the political ocean, it is worth watching him and his party how he swims and make a difference against those who are swimming with the current. In fact, assuming that there is a big chunk of the voters who has been looking for an alternative to the existing political parties , I am not sure what the shape of things will be after the final tally comes up. May be unexpected may again happen in some degree as it happened in Delhi .

      Delete
  7. First of all kudos to uncle for the nice article...In my opinion, we should support leaders like Mr Kejriwal....reason being he has atleast done something in mere 49 days which other gov cannot do in 10 years...Agreed he made mistakes but let not judge him based on such small mistakes... Our country needs honest visionary leader and in my eyes he is one among them... Corruption is the most important issue of our country and he is the one who push the Jan lokpal bill in Delhi which other refuse to pass... I also support his timely exit from the gov because we all know his gov is bound to fall today or tomorrow. So better leave on our own terms... I strongly feel his move will make him win the next Delhi election and come to power in full strength...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Awneesh, I agree that a leader like him should be supported , not because he has 'atleast done something' which in fact is nothing or say, nothing could be done in so short a period as he was in, but because it was worth trying a new emerging political force as against traditional politicians.And now , having watched him so far on the national scene, it becomes clear that it will be futile to repose faith in him for bringing about any marked change in the political arena. He has merged with current and is swimming with current. And that is because he is only an activist and no more . And certainly not a visionary. Nevertheless, he with his party is a factor now and hence needs to be watched till the final dates of elections. May be something unexpected may occur as it did in couse of Delhi elections.

      Delete
  8. The expectations from Kejriwal were huge largely because of the frustrations of the middle class. I agree that it was hard to believe that he would be a game changer even till a few months ago. But now he is a man in a hurry. Its just not his implusive nature but probably greed somewhere which is making him behave like this. I hope, like you said, that the would take advise from more learned political minds and hopefully he and his party will mature over the next 4-5 years to provide a strong left-of-centre leadership which could be a credible opposition to the main parties.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Shashank , why I think that he is impulsive is that he does not have the patience to give a cool thought to any thing . In my opinion greed is not the factor that is prompting him to behave the way he is behaving, for, were it so , he would have been cool and calculative like a shrewd business guy. As I said in my blog , he is blessed with enviable leadership qualities and is able to pull crowds as a leader , but a few of major flaws in his personality undo every thing that perhaps he can do in the interest of the country . Even now , with all his shortcomings ,I am not sure that he will not repeat something similar to what he did to Delhi elections. If nothing else, he is a game changer in politics . Nothing more should be expected from him.

      Delete
    2. Greed not in monetary terms but more in terms of playing a bigger role in the political landscape. Yes, i agree that repeating Delhi poll's performance is going to be tough but he should be able to provide a strong oppostion.

      Delete